Pfister Insurance
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Insurance
    • Personal Insurance
    • Commercial Insurance
  • Resources
    • Carriers
    • Referral Rewards
    • Community Links
    • Emergency Service Providers
    • News
  • Get a Quote Business
    • Get a Quote for Business
    • Get a Quote for Individuals
    • Life Insurance
  • Contact
  • File a claim
Select Page

File A Claim

During normal business hours, feel free to contact your Pfister insurance representative, or call us toll free at 1-800-237-7595.

For emergency claims, or after hours service, feel free to contact your policy carrier directly for assistance. No matter what your situation, never hesitate to reach out to us. Pfister Insurance Agency is here to help!

Westfield Insurance

1-866-937-2663

Visit Website

Travelers Insurance

1-800-252-4633

Visit Website

Frankenmuth Insurance

1-800-234-4433

Visit Website

Safeco Insurance

1-877-566-6001

Visit Website

American Automobile Association

1-866-222-7198

Visit Website

MetLife

1-800-854-6011

Visit Website

Progressive

1-800-274-4499

Visit Website

Ohio Mutual Insurance Group

1-888-895-7725

Visit Website

Foremost Insurance Group

1-800-527-3907

Visit Website

American Collectors Insurance

1-800-360-2277

Visit Website

AmTrust Financial

1-866-272-9267

Visit Website

Erie Insurance

1-800-367-3743

Visit Website

American Strategic Insurance

1-866-274-5677

Visit Website

Pekin Insurance

1-800-322-0160

Visit Website

West Bend

1-877-922-5246

Visit Website

Looking for help?

Click here to view our list of emergency service providers.

Contact Us

Home Office

11807 Royalton Rd
North Royalton, OH 44133

(440) 237-8484

Westerville Office

279 N State St, Ste 200
Westerville, OH 43081

(800) 237-7595

Sharon Center Office

1310 Sharon Copley Rd.
Sharon Center, OH 44274

(800) 237-7595

Lorain Office

 112 East 19th Street
Lorain, Ohio 44052

(800) 237-7595

Navigate

Personal Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Property & Equipment
About Us
Resources
Emergency Services
Helpful Links
Insurance News
Contact Us
Get a Quote

Connect

Follow Us!